Tutorial: plane truss

Build a small statically determinate truss from hinged bars, check its bar forces with the method of joints and the method of sections, and check a deflection by virtual work.

  • Time: about 20 minutes.
  • You need: EduBeam open in a second tab, on a computer with a mouse and keyboard. The Quick start, or one of the tutorials before this one, if you have not used EduBeam before.
  • Background: the method of joints and the method of sections. The optional deflection check uses the unit load method (virtual work).
  • Units: SI. The units chip at the bottom right of the viewer should read m m² kN kNm MPa. If it shows feet and kips, click it and set Unit system to SI (metric).

You will learn to

  • model truss bars as beam elements with both end hinges, drawn with the mouse,
  • check bar forces by the method of joints and the method of sections,
  • spot a zero-force member, and see why a pin-jointed model works for a truss.
The finished truss: 30 kN at nodes 2 and 3, bar forces with tension positive404040−50−40−5030304 m4 m4 m12 m3 m30 kN30 kN3030123456
The finished truss: 30 kN at nodes 2 and 3, bar forces with tension positiveOpen in EduBeam

The problem

  • A 12 m span in three 4 m panels, 3 m deep: bottom chord nodes 1 to 4, top chord nodes 5 and 6.
  • A pin at node 1 and a roller at node 4.
  • Two loads of 30 kN, at the bottom-chord nodes 2 and 3.
  • Steel bars, GPa, cm².
ElementsBars, by their nodes
1, 2, 31–2, 2–3, 3–4bottom chord
4, 5, 61–5, 5–6, 6–4end diagonal, top chord, end diagonal
7, 8, 92–5, 5–3, 3–6vertical, middle diagonal, vertical

Is it determinate? With bars, reactions and joints, . Each joint gives two equations of equilibrium, so the bar forces follow from statics alone.

Model it

Material and section

  1. Click Clear mesh in the app bar, tick Delete materials and Delete cross sections, and click Confirm. Nodes and elements are numbered from 1 again.
  2. Materials tab → Material library → + on the Steel (S235) row, then Cancel to close the library.
  3. Cross sections tab → Add cross section. Type 0.002 in Area and 1e-6 in Iy, keep Height and Shear coefficient at 1, and click Add cross section.

With hinged bars only the area matters; just has to be positive.

Draw the bars with hinges

A truss bar in EduBeam is a beam element with both end hinges ticked. The mouse tool can tick them for you, and the order you draw in gives the numbers in the table above.

  1. Elements tab → the second Add element button, the one with the cursor icon.
  2. In the banner at the top of the viewer, tick Start hinge and End hinge. Every bar you draw now gets both.
  3. Bottom chord: click (0, 0), (4, 0), (8, 0) and (12, 0), then press Esc.
  4. Top: click the Add element button again, then node 1 at (0, 0), (4, −3), (8, −3) and node 4 at (12, 0). Clicking an existing node connects to it instead of adding a new one. Press Esc.
  5. Web: once more, click node 2 at (4, 0), node 5 at (4, −3), node 3 at (8, 0) and node 6 at (8, −3). Press Esc, then F to fit the view.

The Elements table should now list the nine elements of the table above, each with both End hinges ticked. Esc leaves the drawing mode, but the hinge boxes in the banner stay ticked for the next time.

Supports and loads

  1. Click node 1 → Node supports → the Pin symbol. Give node 4 the Roller.
  2. Click node 2 → Add load → Fz = 30 → Add nodal load. Do the same at node 3.

Positive Fz points down. Every bar at a joint is hinged, so nothing holds the joint against rotation; EduBeam accepts that and reports the rotation of such a node as 0.

Results

In the display options at the top right of the viewer (the cog shows and hides them), untick Deformed shape and My (x), as there is no bending in a truss, and tick N (x). Tension is positive, and EduBeam labels the forces in kN with two decimals.

  • Both supports read 30.00 upward; the pin's horizontal reaction reads 0.00, as no horizontal load acts.
  • The bottom chord reads 40.00 in all three bars, tension; the top chord -40.00, compression.
  • The middle diagonal, 5–3, carries nothing, so it has no label, as in the figure at the top.
  • Results tab → Nodal results: node 2 moves down by = 2.2937 · 10⁻³ m, that is 2.294 mm.

Check by hand

Reactions. The loads are symmetric, so kN upward, and with no horizontal load the pin's horizontal reaction is zero.

Joint 1 (method of joints). The end diagonal 1–5 is 5 m long, so and :

Joint 2. The vertical 2–5 is the only bar that can carry the 30 kN load up: kN, and kN.

Section through the middle panel (method of sections). Cut bars 5–6, 5–3 and 2–3 and keep the left part:

  • Moments about node 3: kN.
  • Vertical forces: the shear in the panel is , so the middle diagonal 5–3 carries nothing: .
BarsBy handEduBeam
Bottom chord 1–2, 2–3, 3–4+40 kN, tension40.00
Top chord 5–6−40 kN, compression−40.00
End diagonals 1–5, 6–4−50 kN−50.00
Verticals 2–5, 3–6+30 kN30.00
Middle diagonal 5–30no label

A zero-force member is not a useless one: it carries nothing under this load, but take it away and the truss collapses, as the experiments below show.

The deflection of node 2, by virtual work

Put a unit load downward at node 2 and solve the truss again by hand: , , and the bar forces below. The deflection is :

Bar (kN) (m)
1–2408/94142.2
2–3408/94142.2
3–4404/9471.1
1–5−50−10/95277.8
5–6−40−4/9471.1
6–4−50−5/95138.9
2–5301390.0
5–30−5/950
3–6301/3330.0
sum963.3

That is 2.294 mm, the same as EduBeam's of node 2, 2.2937 · 10⁻³ m.

Experiment

Change one thing at a time, predict the result, then look. Ctrl+Z takes each change back.

Move one load. Put both loads at node 2: delete the load at node 3 and change the other to Fz = 60. Now kN, the shear in the middle panel is kN, and the middle diagonal has to carry it: kN, in compression.

60 kN at node 2: the middle diagonal 5–3 now carries the panel shear53.3353.3326.67−66.67−26.67−33.3360−33.332060 kN4020123456
60 kN at node 2: the middle diagonal 5–3 now carries the panel shearOpen in EduBeam

Remove the middle diagonal. Delete element 8. The middle panel becomes a hinged rectangle that can shear sideways. EduBeam shows no results, reports The hinges at nodes 2, 3, 5, 6 let the structure move., the four corners of that panel, and animates the motion.

Untick all the hinges in the Elements table. The truss becomes a frame with rigid joints. Tick My (x): the bending moments stay below 0.1 kNm and the normal forces change by less than 0.1 %. That is why the pin-jointed idealisation works for a triangulated truss.

Pin both supports. A fourth reaction makes the truss once indeterminate, and the result may surprise you: the bottom chord now carries nothing, and each support pushes inward by 40 kN instead. Nodes 1 and 4 cannot move apart, so the three bars of the chord between them, in line, must have a total elongation of zero. They all carry the same force, so that force is zero, and its 40 kN goes into the supports. This holds whatever the bar areas.

Both supports pinned: the supports take over the job of the bottom chord−50−40−50303030 kN30 kN40304030123456
Both supports pinned: the supports take over the job of the bottom chordOpen in EduBeam

Next steps

The theory behind the bar element is in Truss element.